Top 10 Best Shopify Warranties and Insurance Apps in 2023 [manually tested]

Are you looking for the best Shopify warranties and insurance app to provide your brand with an extra layer of reliability and quality in your customers’ eyes?

E-commerce warranties and insurance apps attach a promise to the products you offer your customers. Warranties and insurance signify that your products are of higher quality, flexible, and come with trusted protection in case of damage or loss.

The right Shopify insurance app, coupled with good customer service, can turn a one-time shopper into a repeat customer. After all, it’ll be hard for a customer to bounce when their products come with a warranty and insurance covering the shipping process and are easy to claim, extend, or cancel.

Top 10 Best Shopify Warranties and Insurance Apps

It’s time to choose the perfect Shopify warranty app to reinforce your products’ value with added protection and encourage customers to believe in what you’re selling.

But as a busy entrepreneur, you may not have time to try all the warranty apps in the Shopify store to find the best Shopify warranties and insurance app for your store.

No worries, we’ve done the probing for you!

We tested and reviewed many Shopify warranty and insurance apps to find the best 10. The apps selected for this list meet the highest expectations in terms of ease of use, features, integrations, pricing, and customer reviews.

1. Captain Shipping Protection

Captain Shipping Protection

Customer Rating: 4.9/5 (over 56 reviews)

Key Features

Captain Shipping Protection is the best Shopify warranty app for merchants seeking top-notch features that offer self-managed insurance with significant revenues.

Few warranty apps let you keep 100% of what is collected while allowing self-managed insurance like Captain Shipping Insurance does. It is a great warranty and insurance app for sellers who don’t want to deal with shipping insurance providers to serve their customers. All shipping protection premiums are yours to keep.

Partnering with an innovative tech platform, and ParcelPanel, Captain Shipping Insurance allows you to provide your customers with shipping insurance, tracking, and loyalty programs in one place.

Create the best warranty and insurance programs with customizable cart and checkout pages to boost customer loyalty to your products.

  • Easy to set up exclusions and insurance fulfillment settings
  • Carbon-neutral shipping with additional revenue going to environmental protection
  • Seamless integration to stores and match brand theme
  • Integration with ParcelPanel Returns app
  • Multi-currency conversion

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Easy to set up There is no option to add to the cart on the checkout page
Customizable insurance widgets It may not work well with custom themes
Quick and responsive customer support
Merchants keep 100% of insurance premiums.
It does not affect site loading speed.

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps

Checkout, Checkout Extensibility, checkout page, Cart page, Returns & Exchanges, and Order tracking

Pricing Plans

1.    14-day free trial

2.    Standard plan @ $11/month

2. Simply Shipping Protection

Simply Shipping Protection

Customer Rating: 4.9/5 (over 118 reviews)

Key Features

The best Shopify warranty app for merchants who want to provide their insurance. No third-party insurers are needed.

Simply Shipping Protection allows you to create and manage your own insurance plans, which saves you money by eliminating third-party insurers. You get an easy-to-integrate and navigate interface with customization options and automatic protection coverage to streamline the claims process for your customers. The app gives you complete control of your insurance program. You set up charges and decide how to fulfill the claims.

Boost confidence in your product by updating customers on the status of their claims with this Shopify warranty app.

  • Multiple ways to fulfill claims like partial or full refunds reorders, and in-store credit
  • Upselling and cross-selling capabilities
  • In-depth report on claims and revenues
  • Seamless integration with popular Shopify apps

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Easy to set up and user-friendly interface Claims management is limited to just one language: English
Perfect for adding free order-value There is no description field in the cart section to explain the insurance
Reliable customer service support
Compatible with various brand themes
Customizable auto shipping protection feature

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps

Checkout, Rebuy, Cart Drawer, iCart Drawer, Slide Cart, Flits, and Recharge

Pricing Plans

1.    Free plan with up to 50 insured orders/month

2.    Basic plan @ $19.99/month

3.    Advance plan @ $49.99/month

4.    Enterprise plan @ $100/month

3. Guide Shipping Protection

Guide Shipping Protection

Customer Rating: 4.7/5 (over 80 reviews)

Key Features

Guide is the best Shopify warranty and insurance app for merchants looking for a fast and affordable way to settle insurance claims coverage

For your online marketplace, Guide Shipping Insurance allows you to resolve claims in record time with instant resolutions. If there’s a claim on a lost, damaged, or stolen package, the app resolves it with a repurchase from your site. Additionally, Guide Shipping Protection gives merchants added revenue by providing full MSRP replacements with their approve-all-claims model.

You get all these features absolutely free. This Shopify insurance app collects the money charged to customers for shipping protection.

  • The guide gives customers protection from theft, damage, chargebacks, etc.
  • Checkout feature that supports checkout extensibility
  • Seamless integration with popular Shopify apps
  • Supports checkout extensibility

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Safe installs and uninstalls Subpar customer service
Free to install No customization
Turns shipping issues into loyalty
Affordable insurance charges

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps

Checkout, Cart Drawer, Headless, ReBuy, shipping insurance, and shipping protection

Pricing Plans

Free to install.

4. Navidium Shipping Protection

Navidium Shipping Protection

Customer Rating: 5/5 (over 256 reviews)

Key Features

Navidium Shopify insurance app is great for merchants who want to create self-funded shipping protection plans.

Navidium lets you control your customer’s shipping journey by allowing you to manage claims and improve the user experience with smooth opt-ins and opt-outs. Control how much to charge customers based on a percentage of the cart value or pricing tiers. You also get to keep 100% of the collected charges, which you can use to cover claims. What is left is your profit.

With upselling and cross-selling capabilities, comprehensive reports, and a user-friendly interface, Navidium is the best option if you require a robust Shopify warranty app.

  • Generate revenue with shipping protection fees.
  • Seamless integration and is compatible with all cart types
  • Negate loss on damaged and lost packages with digital product cart upsell
  • One-click refunds and reorders
  • Flexible and fully customizable for branded and non-branded pages

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
User-friendly interface Few bugs in the software
Fully customizable to match brand theme
Seamless integration with popular Shopify apps
Routes insurance protection fees back to you
Passive upsell

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps

Shipping Insurance, Shipping Protection, Upsell, Rebuy Cart, Slide Cart, and Subscriptions.

Pricing Plans

1.    7-day free trial on paid plans

2.    Free plan

3.    Essential plan @ $29.99/month

4.    Growth plan @ $49.99/month

5.    Enterprise – Plus plan @ $99.99/month

5. Route: Post-Purchase Platform

Route: Post-Purchase Platform

Customer Rating: 3.9/5 (over 355 reviews)

Key Features

Route is the best Shopify warranties and insurance app for merchants seeking a comprehensive tool to settle claims and reduce support costs.

Route is a one-stop solution platform for giving customers the best post-purchase experience. The app allows you to transform your customer’s shopping journey with shipping insurance, tracking, and remarketing tools. You get to provide your customers orders with protection against damage, loss, or theft while getting valuable insights into the filled claims.

Give your customers peace of mind and personalized product recommendations with this Shopify shipping insurance app and watch one-time customers become repeat buyers.

  • Parcel tracking and shipping insurance in one place
  • Carbon-neutral shipping to protect the environment
  • Reduce support costs and claim resolution time
  • Product recommendations to increase a customer’s lifetime value

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Customer order tracking There is no option to insure every product automatically
Makes reimbursing easy It hardly integrates with any Shopify app
Affordable to small businesses
Easy to set up and has a user-friendly interface.

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps:

Works well with Checkout.

Pricing Plans

1.    Free to install

2.    Free basic plan

3.    Pro plan @ $349/month

4.    Custom plan

6. InsureShield Package Protect

InsureShield Package Protect

Customer Rating: 4.5/5 (over 42 reviews)

Key Features

InsureShield is the best Shopify insurance app for merchants seeking a quick way to settle claims with pay-as-you-go protection.

A great way to increase repeat customers and positive reviews is by settling claims quickly, which is what InsureShield does best. This Shopify warranty app ensures customers get reliable product protection, with claims usually resolved in a few days. Merchants get to set up automatic order coverage, while customers can choose to protect their orders at checkout.

InsureShield covers all your shipments for carriers like UPS, DHL, FedEx, and USPS in one place, so your customers don’t have to deal with a lousy shipping experience for long.

  • Package coverage against loss, porch piracy, and damage
  • Protection of shipments based on value, geo, or SKU with flexible rules
  • Direct app sync with Shopify store and applies insurance preferences on fulfilled orders
  • App deals with all filled claims, so merchants don’t have to deal with carriers

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Fast refunds and reorders It does not work well with store pickups or local delivery
Saves time by dealing directly with claims
24/7 reliable customer service
Quick-to-install and user-friendly interface

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps:

Debut, Dawn, Minimal, Brooklyn, Venture, And More!

Pricing Plans

Free to install – Additional charges apply.

7. Clyde | Warranty Platform

Clyde | Warranty Platform

Customer Rating: 3.4/5 (over 34 reviews)

Key Features

Clyde is the best Shopify warranties and insurance app for providing customers with an added layer of protection with an extended warranty program.

For some customers, an extended warranty, especially for expensive products, is a sign of quality and reliability from the brand that puts their minds at ease. Clyde empowers small businesses and enterprises to offer product protection with extended warranty programs directly under the store owner’s control. You can add calls to action at any stage of the purchase flow while providing extended warranty upsells.

Customers receive an exceptional purchasing experience with an entire claims platform to file claims conveniently. As for merchants, this Shopify shipping insurance app offers a dashboard that provides comprehensive reports and metrics to aid in managing and controlling your insurance programs.

  • Extended warranty upsells boost customer retention rates
  • Increase average order value and give your customers peace of mind with a robust warranty program
  • Shopify Plus Certified App partner

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Seamless integration and user-friendly interface Integrates with a few Shopify apps
Accidental damage warranties Only available for US customers
Reliable customer support service
Great margins
Automatically matches warranties to the products on the back end.

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps:

Checkout, Attentive, Gorgias, and Klaviyo

Pricing Plans

Free to install – Clyde receives a commission per warranty sold.

8. ShipTection


Customer Rating: 5/5 (over 29 reviews)

Key Features

If you’re looking for a quick and straightforward way to offer shipping insurance with excellent revenues, then this Shopify shipping insurance app is the way to go.

ShipTection provides an easy way to give your customers peace of mind with shipping protection against loss, damage, and theft during transit. And while your customers get an amazing post-purchase experience, this Shopify warranty app lets you keep some of the revenue generated.

Customers can choose to get shipping protection at checkout, and if anything goes wrong during shipping, the app provides a simple claims process.

  • Excellent revenue-sharing feature for merchants to make extra money on insurance
  • Straightforward claims process that doesn’t force customers to download an app or bombard them with marketing emails
  • Seamless integration with Shopify stores

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Revenue share Integrates with hardly any other Shopify app
Free to download and use for a lifetime
Easy to set up
Reliable customer support service

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps

None at the moment.

Pricing Plan

Free to install – The app charges merchants based on the revenue generated from shipping protection.

9. Green Shipping Protection

Green Shipping Protection

Customer Rating: 5/5 (over 26 reviews)

Key Features

Corso is the best Shopify warranties and insurance app for offering customers quick claims resolutions and environmentally friendly shipping protection.

Designed with customers’ peace of mind and the environment in mind, Corso can elevate your brand experience by going above and beyond with their services. With this Shopify insurance app, customers can add Green Shipping Protection at checkout to protect their packages from theft, loss, or damage. In case of an order issue, customers can deal directly with Corso and have their order replaced without charging you.

Resolution of order claims takes no more than 24 hours with a 60-day claim window.

  • Saves time and adds revenue with full MSRP replacements
  • Checkout extensibility provides customers with a smooth experience
  • 2% charge on the customer’s cart value
  • Calculates the customer
    ’s carbon footprint and the cost to offset
  • Hyper-focused on response time and customer satisfaction

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Small branded widgets optimized not to affect site performance Offers limited control to merchants
Excellent customer support service
Free protection plan for merchants
Easy to set up and navigate
Excellent claims resolution time

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps:

Checkout, Recharge, Gorgias, Klaviyo, Rebuy, Headless, and Zendesk

Pricing Plans

Free to install – This Shopify shipping insurance app is free to merchants. Funds are charged to customers for carbon offsets and shipping insurance.

10. Alert Me! Restock Alerts

Alert Me! Restock Alerts

Customer Rating: 4.8 (over 375 reviews)

Key Features

Alert Me is one of the best Shopify apps to bolster customer engagement and retention with back-in-stock alerts.

While not a shipping protection app per se, this app is an effective tool for managing your inventory and understanding your customers’ preferences. You can complement Alert Me with an all-in-one e-commerce solutions platform to provide tracking, shipping protection, and loyalty rewards to your customers.

Customers can sign up for automatic back-in-stock alerts when their favorite products are available. It is a convenient and effortless way to engage with your customers and boost their lifetime value.

  • Convenient marketing with automatic back-in-store alerts
  • Instant alerts to all your customers effortlessly
  • Alerts are customizable to match the brand theme
  • Comprehensive analytics to gauge the most requested products

Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Customizable alert messages No shipping protection feature
Boost customer engagement Hardly compatible with any Shopify app
Reliable customer support
It helps eliminate excessive inventory.

Integrated with Other Popular Shopify Apps:

None at the moment.

Pricing Plans

1.    Free Plan

2.    Growth Plan @ $9.99/month

3.    Pro Plan @ $29.99/month


Now that you know the best warranty apps in Shopify, it’s time to find out how to pick the right one for your store.

Customization options, automated operational tasks, product coverage flexibility, pricing adjustments and revenue, regular reporting and analytics, and responsive support service are the most important factors to bear in mind. Make sure these factors work well with your store, and you’re set to go.

Give us a try

See how Channelwill can grow your business

Related blog posts

Join The World's Fastest-Growing Brands

Scroll to Top